| This Month's Best | Best Active | Best Inactive | Pick a Creator | Pick a Category | All |
| New Survey | Replies | Users | Search | Chat | Forum | Feedback | Statistics | Customize | Help |
| Type | Created | Category | Creator | Sort | Votes | Hides | Rating | |
| single | 17-Aug-2008 | opinion | LindaH | by votes | 39 | 4 | 56.9% |
|
| User | Comment |
|---|---|
| kcthedog | posted 18-Aug-2008 12:30am Being passive is being reserved and subtle, when one feels apathy, one doesn’t give a crap! |
| Melf | posted 18-Aug-2008 3:11am Way no. |
| bill | posted 18-Aug-2008 6:39am I'll say "yes", whatever! |
| justjulie | posted 18-Aug-2008 7:48am no |
| romkey | posted 18-Aug-2008 10:18am No. Passivity is about not doing something. Apathy is about not caring. People may conflate them when making an argument but they're not the same thing. |
| LJD | posted 18-Aug-2008 10:52am No...apathy=indifference...passivity=inactive |
| Jody | posted 18-Aug-2008 1:21pm Apathy means not caring about it (whatever "it" is). Passivity indicates the person isn't doing anything about it, but implies nothing about whether they care or not. |
| cloudhugger | posted 18-Aug-2008 6:08pm No, two completely different things. Apathy is not giving a crap, passivity is walking away from crap. |
| jettles | posted 18-Aug-2008 6:13pm not really, the ends may look close but the emotion or thought process isn't the same. someone who is passive can feel really strongly about something and not act on it but someone who is apathetic usually doesn't feel it or do anything |
| JessicaWoman99 | posted 18-Aug-2008 8:43pm No i do not have any idea |
| southernyankee | posted 19-Aug-2008 12:46am Yep, pretty much. Apathy usually causes passivity. |
| Kristal_Rose | posted 19-Aug-2008 3:23am No. You can take in just whatever is present and be quite into it. |
| bill | (reply to romkey) posted 19-Aug-2008 8:23am I had the same thought, but the question was whether they "amount to the same thing".
In both cases, the result is likely that the person does nothing, so perhaps the answers is "yes". |
| justjulie | (reply to bill) posted 19-Aug-2008 8:44am they do indeed technically amount to the same thing, being "nothing" as the end result.
However, the difference is in the 'tone' of the word. "Passivity" carries w/ it a tone of indifference, but in a balanced way...it's neutral. Now, "apathy" carries w/ it a tone of bitterness/sourness, making it be negative... so...yeah, they amount to the same thing, but sing a slightly different tune along the way |
| justjulie | posted 19-Aug-2008 8:45am *just changed vote to "Other"*
|
| bill | (reply to justjulie) posted 19-Aug-2008 8:52am I thought of a third case that might amount to the same thing... ambivalence. |
| justjulie | (reply to bill) posted 19-Aug-2008 9:01am ahhhhhhhh...indeed! and this one carries a more "positive" tone... |
| LindaH | (reply to justjulie) posted 19-Aug-2008 10:51am I think of apathy as indifference, passivity as non-confrontational. A person can care very much, no indifference at all, but not want to make waves, thus: passivity. |
| Matty | posted 19-Aug-2008 12:13pm Amount to? I think you can make a viable argument for that. However, pacifism is not apathetic. It has been my experience that pacifists hold their beliefs viscerally. |
| justjulie | (reply to LindaH) posted 19-Aug-2008 1:58pm right...i was saying how the word 'feels' to me; not speaking of exact definition |
| Enheduanna | posted 20-Aug-2008 8:10am I don't think so. |
| Cain | posted 20-Aug-2008 4:20pm According to their dictionary definitions - no. |
| caviartaste | posted 24-Aug-2008 1:18am I think that passivity is a situation in which you could but you don't/won't do something (requires self-awareness) ....whereas apathy denotes desensitization to the fact that there's anything to be done at all. |
If you'd like to vote and/or comment on this survey, please Sign On
| This Month's Best | Best Active | Best Inactive | Pick a Creator | Pick a Category | All |
| New Survey | Replies | Users | Search | Chat | Forum | Feedback | Statistics | Customize | Help |