| This Month's Best | Best Active | Best Inactive | Pick a Creator | Pick a Category | All |
| New Survey | Replies | Users | Search | Chat | Forum | Feedback | Statistics | Customize | Help |
| Type | Created | Category | Creator | Sort | Votes | Hides | Rating | |
| multiple | 30-May-2008 | books/literature | aquawolfy | by votes | 39 | 4 | 59.5% |
|
| User | Comment |
|---|---|
| Melf | posted 31-May-2008 3:47pm |
| LindaH | posted 31-May-2008 3:56pm No. I can't remember any details in it, but I remember knowing that people found it offensive, reading it, and not finding anything offensive. |
| ausfox | posted 31-May-2008 6:11pm No, it's a classic. |
| Psychopath | posted 31-May-2008 6:27pm While I personally did not find the book to be offensive. I would not want my child reading this book unless he were at least in high school (16 or older) because there is quite a bit of swearing in it. Also, I don' think that the main character's outlook on life is really a one I would want my child to share.
By the way, I thought it was good and entertaining book but I did not quite understand why it is considered a literary classic? |
| bill | posted 31-May-2008 7:12pm I liked this book. I just read it a couple years ago. Compared to many more recent books, it's quite tame and not offensive at all. I think it has the f-word in it, and a situation with a prostitute. |
| Galomorro | posted 31-May-2008 9:22pm No, I don't believe it's offensive. |
| kirst | posted 31-May-2008 9:26pm I've never read it. |
| Pomeranian | posted 1-Jun-2008 3:28am "quaint" is the most polite way I could describe anybody who finds "The Catcher in the Rye" offensive. |
| they | posted 1-Jun-2008 7:30am It's not offensive at all.
It's also pretty boring. |
| JessicaWoman99 | posted 1-Jun-2008 1:50pm I have not read or seen this book to say whether it is offensive or not |
| cloudhugger | posted 1-Jun-2008 5:05pm No, it's fine. I read it when I was young, I found it...unrememberable. |
| Jody | posted 2-Jun-2008 1:38pm I remember reading it in junior high school and not liking it much. |
| judgescratch | posted 2-Jun-2008 3:50pm No. I don't believe the book is offensive.
|
| Zang | posted 3-Jun-2008 1:00pm I read it when I was about 20. It was okay. I don't know what people these days would find so offensive about it. As I recall, the narrator says "gosh darn" a lot. Oh my! |
| Biggles | posted 4-Jun-2008 2:15pm I cannot imagine how anyone could regard the Catcher in The Rye as offensive unless they think that only carefree and innocent young people should ever be portrayed in books... |
| Cleo | posted 13-Jun-2008 12:56pm I've never read the book BUT, I've seen the movie. |
| Biggles | posted 14-Jun-2008 2:11pm I've just reread The Catcher in the Rye because of this survey. I can understand why people might have been shocked about it when it was first published. I can understand someone not wanting a 10 year old child reading it because it does mention sex a lot. I don't really see anything offensive about it though, unless you are the type of person who is always going to be offended by anything that isn't The Waltons.
I also thought it was a fantastic book and I definitely read it in a very different way this time. Last time I read it, I was probably about the same age as Holden and I found him quite repulsive (though I mellowed towards him by the end of the book). Reading it a few years later allows me to be a little more objective and see it in the context of everything that's happening to you when you're a teenager (which is obviously taken far into extremes in his case because he's also pretty messed up) so I could feel a lot more sympathy and empathy for him. I've read some other Salinger, but nothing comes close to matching this. |
| kcthedog | posted 15-Jun-2008 1:32am I was bummed it didn't have pictures. |
| aquawolfy | posted 21-Jun-2008 6:36pm Yeah, according to a lot of people I've talked to, Holden does have a mental illness. I forgot the name. I'll have to look it up again.....
But i did and still do find Holden to be a very likeable character. =D |
If you'd like to vote and/or comment on this survey, please Sign On
| This Month's Best | Best Active | Best Inactive | Pick a Creator | Pick a Category | All |
| New Survey | Replies | Users | Search | Chat | Forum | Feedback | Statistics | Customize | Help |
I don't even like it that much (eh cynicism), but I don't find it offensive.