Survey Central
Sign On
Create Account

This Month's BestBest ActiveBest InactivePick a CreatorPick a CategoryAll
New SurveyRepliesUsersSearchChatForumFeedbackStatisticsCustomizeHelp


Last

Type Created Category Creator Sort Votes Hides Rating
multiple11-Jan-2008ethics/moralityCrayons Bronze Star Survey CreatorSurvey Qualifierby votes39459.5%

  Is this an ironic conversation?

"I don't believe in god"
"That's a sin!"

Isn't it kind of useless that my mom told me it's a sin not to believe in God? Or does she make sense in some way?

VotesAnswer
11That's kind of funny
9No, it makes perfect sense because...
5Well, that's ironic
5Other
4Uh...

UserComment
Melf Survey Central SubscriberBronze Star Survey CreatorGold Qualifier
posted 12-Jan-2008 7:22pm  

It borders on irony. It's having a little tap dance on the side lines.
JessicaWoman99
posted 12-Jan-2008 7:25pm  

No it makes perfect sense because there is a God and Jesus and all the reasons to believe
Enheduanna Survey Central Subscriber
posted 12-Jan-2008 7:27pm  

No, it's not ironic. It's just a failure to communicate. In her world, there is a God, and therefore it's wrong not to believe in him. In your world, there is no God, so it's only logical not to believe in him. You just have different worldviews.
romkey Survey Central Gold Subscriber
posted 12-Jan-2008 8:58pm  

It makes sense from her perspective... just not from yours.
kcthedog Survey Central Gold Subscriber
posted 12-Jan-2008 9:14pm  

Sin? What is sin? God does not judge someone because of disbelief; he realizes that someone that has not come to know him cannot be held responsible for a mistaken idea. Just so I do not invoke the wrath of atheists if God does exist he would judge based on intent not so much on action. God would realize, being God that when it is all said and done evil and goodness will nullify each other. All that really matters is that we live a life of fellowship respecting everyone and everything sharing love and kindness.
LindaH Survey Central Gold SubscriberGold Star Survey CreatorSurvey Qualifier
(reply to kcthedog) posted 12-Jan-2008 9:17pm  

*yes*
cloudhugger Survey Central SubscriberSilver Star Survey CreatorSurvey Qualifier
posted 12-Jan-2008 11:12pm  

It's funny, it's ironic and it makes sense because of the logical implication that organized religions have to offer.
It would make a great punch line for a joke. I could see this as a skit that could go on, kind like a Bristish comedy maybe.
bill Survey Central Gold SubscriberSilver Star Survey Creator
posted 13-Jan-2008 8:38am  

From your mother's perspective, it makes sense. But, the nice thing is that you have your own perspective.
Biggles
posted 13-Jan-2008 9:28am  

No, that's not irony. Irony would be more like you saying "I don't believe in God but I'm worried that's a sin." There's nothing ironic about your mother's response - that's exactly what you'd expect a religious person to say...

Okay, I'm British and we're irony snobs...
Biggles
(reply to cloudhugger) posted 13-Jan-2008 9:30am  

It's not that far off some documentaries that Richard Dawkins has made.
they Survey Central SubscriberBronze Star Survey Creator
posted 13-Jan-2008 9:43am  

Yeah, I get this sometimes.

I think it just shows you how ignorant and narrow minded the religious can be.
cloudhugger Survey Central SubscriberSilver Star Survey CreatorSurvey Qualifier
(reply to Biggles) posted 13-Jan-2008 11:00pm  

I could see it developing in my head. And it kept getting funnier. Canned laughter and everything.
Biggles
(reply to cloudhugger) posted 14-Jan-2008 10:16am  

Ugh - I hate canned laughter.
icurok Bronze Star Survey Creator
posted 14-Jan-2008 10:19am  

Irony is where the literal meaning is the opposite of the actual meaning. Irony is not a byword for 'a bit weird'.

This is not irony.
icurok Bronze Star Survey Creator
(reply to Biggles) posted 14-Jan-2008 10:20am  

Aren't we just.
Biggles
(reply to icurok) posted 14-Jan-2008 10:35am  

And tuned in too.
southernyankee Bronze Star Survey Creator
posted 15-Jan-2008 11:00am  

Not really ironic. But funny. I don't get why God would care if you believe in him anyway.
judgescratch
posted 15-Jan-2008 3:49pm  

no
icurok Bronze Star Survey Creator
(reply to southernyankee) posted 16-Jan-2008 10:32am  

"For I, the LORD your God, am a jealous God." Exodus 20:5
southernyankee Bronze Star Survey Creator
(reply to icurok) posted 16-Jan-2008 11:39am  

Thats only problematic if you go ahead and worship OTHER Gods. If the person doesn't believe in ANY Gods, wheres the jealously? Thats like getting jealous that a member of your preferred sex that you find attractive turns out to be asexual.
RGirl
posted 25-Jan-2008 7:27pm  

Kind of funny? It's hilarious.
i_LUV_MV
posted 3-Feb-2008 5:24pm  

Well, the irony is, if you don't believe in God, why would you be afraid of committing sin?
LJD Bronze Star Survey CreatorGold Qualifier
posted 29-Mar-2008 4:38pm  

It's unwise to not believe in God. It is a parent's responsibility to teach his/her children of God's teaching, teaching the principles of life with God's Word.



If you'd like to vote and/or comment on this survey, please Sign On.

 
Link this survey: http://surveycentral.org/survey/28613.html

Hits: 1 today (327 in the last 30 days)

Google Search:


This Month's BestBest ActiveBest InactivePick a CreatorPick a CategoryAll
New SurveyRepliesUsersSearchChatForumFeedbackStatisticsCustomizeHelp



Copyright © 1996-2008 Kenyon Hill LLC. All rights reserved.
Advertise on this site - Take our Poll - Privacy Statement - Subscribe - Donate - RSS RSS Feed