Survey Central
Sign On
Create Account

This Month's BestBest ActiveBest InactivePick a CreatorPick a CategoryAll
New SurveyRepliesUsersSearchChatForumFeedbackStatisticsCustomizeHelp


Last

Type Created Category Creator Sort Votes Hides Rating
multiple3-Dec-2007opinionIseult Silver Star Survey Creatorby votes50462.8%

  Is anyone else pissed off about this?

Monday, 26 November 2007
'Muhammad' teddy teacher arrested

Gillian Gibbons is described as "a talented and able teacher "
A British schoolteacher has been arrested in Sudan accused of insulting Islam's Prophet, after she allowed her pupils to name a teddy bear Muhammad.


Colleagues of Gillian Gibbons, 54, from Liverpool, said she made an "innocent mistake" by letting the six and seven-year-olds choose the name.

Ms Gibbons was arrested after several parents made complaints.

The BBC has learned the charge could lead to six months in jail, 40 lashes or a fine.

Officials from the British embassy in Khartoum are expected to visit Ms Gibbons in custody.

"We are in contact with the authorities here and they have visited the teacher and she is in a good condition," an embassy spokesman said.

The spokesman said the naming of the teddy happened months ago and was chosen by the children because it is a common name in the country.

"This happened in September and the parents did not have a problem with it," he said.
Continue reading this article: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/africa/7112929.st...

Update: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7124447.stm

VotesAnswer
18Yes, I'm pissed off about the way the teacher was treated
6Yes, I'm pissed off about another aspect
6Other
5I was unfamiliar with this case until now
4No, I am not pissed off, however...
4No, I am not pissed off
0Yes, I'm pissed off about what she did

UserComment
Enheduanna Survey Central Subscriber
posted 4-Dec-2007 10:26am  

Saddened, but not pissed off. The way I heard it explained, the teddy bear is considered an "idol." I can understand why some people would be offended by naming it Muhammed, but I think it's sad that it went this far. They should understand that she made an innocent mistake.
kcthedog Survey Central Gold Subscriber
posted 4-Dec-2007 10:49am  

I first heard of this situation this morning and I was shocked! The fact that she had already been released circumvented and muted my reaction, otherwise “pissed” I would have been! There so much wrong with this picture I do not even know how to begin to respond! One thing that comes to mind is the loss of their teacher for the young pupils. I am renewed in my appreciation of the freedom of rights in the USA. I am surprised that the British Embassy did not react faster. I am glad she is out of that “less-than-enlightened” country. From what I have read and heard on the radio this morning she was “Brave” and handled herself with dignity and grace.
darkshadowsseeker
posted 4-Dec-2007 11:01am  

Yes, I was pissed off at how she was treated. She didn't even name the teddy bear herself. One of her students, a little boy whose name is Muhammad, asked that the teddy bear be named after him. Granted the Sudanese president gave her a full pardon, but Sudanese Muslim hardliners were completely against that.
Galomorro Bronze Star Survey CreatorGold Qualifier
posted 4-Dec-2007 11:21am  

Yes, I'm pissed off about the way she was treated. People go WAY overboard sometimes, just like they do in America. They just overdo it and lean too far the other way. This is a culture-clash thing and she should just be given a warning.
Irene007 Survey Central Gold Subscriber
posted 4-Dec-2007 11:22am  

Fanatics rise again....
icurok Bronze Star Survey Creator
posted 4-Dec-2007 11:35am  

At least they gave her a pardon in the end.

I think we should send them a batch of these in gratitude

judgescratch
posted 4-Dec-2007 11:54am  

Yes, I'm pissed off about another aspect
Frostbrand Bronze Star Survey Creator
posted 4-Dec-2007 11:55am  

Dogma makes people crazy.

Crap like this explains why I'm an Atheist. Islam, Christianity, Judaism, it's all the same irrational crap.
LindaH Survey Central Gold SubscriberGold Star Survey CreatorSurvey Qualifier
posted 4-Dec-2007 11:55am  

Any country that would choose to punish a non-citizen rather than simply deport them is petty, brutal and vengeful.
Melf Survey Central SubscriberBronze Star Survey CreatorGold Qualifier
posted 4-Dec-2007 12:43pm  

God, whatever.
FauxLo Survey Central Gold SubscriberBronze Star Survey Creator
posted 4-Dec-2007 1:25pm  

FoxTurtle wants to change his name to Muhammad, so...
bill Survey Central Gold SubscriberSilver Star Survey Creator
posted 4-Dec-2007 1:46pm  

Religion sucks, what else is new?
romkey Survey Central Gold Subscriber
posted 4-Dec-2007 2:37pm  

I'm not pissed off about it.

She's already been released.

Of course it's dreadfully stupid. It does make me consider how far I should really go in attempting to respect other people's cultures... every day I respect them less.
cerealkiller Bronze Star Survey CreatorSurvey Qualifier
posted 4-Dec-2007 2:49pm  

I see she's back home in the UK now.
Crayons Bronze Star Survey CreatorSurvey QualifierThis user is on the site NOW (4 minutes and 48 seconds ago)
posted 4-Dec-2007 3:44pm  

Doesn't concern me much, well. Things happen.
justjulie
posted 4-Dec-2007 4:58pm  

dumb...let me guess, somehow this could turn into a hate crime,case, or something, blah -blah-blabbity-blah-blah.
just dumb
llamamama
posted 4-Dec-2007 7:29pm  

We saw this, this morning in mass media class..
I'm not pissed. I mean, I think it's dumb how she was treated..but my emotions don't even begin to reach that of being pissed.
Amanda
posted 4-Dec-2007 7:46pm  

I hadn't heard about this until now. It seems like they are taking things a little too far. I mean, it's a freaking teddy bear and a name. But, they have laws that everyone is expected to go by. If she couldn't follow the laws, no matter how out there, she shouldn't have been there.
dab Survey Central Gold SubscriberSurvey Qualifier
posted 4-Dec-2007 7:59pm  

I used to try to respect sincerely religious people. That has largely gone. Religion is a barbarism that we can not afford.
southernyankee Bronze Star Survey Creator
posted 4-Dec-2007 9:39pm  

I am pissed off because of 1) what radical Islam is doing, 2) that no one is standing up to radical Islam. Clinton had it right when he sent troops to Somalia.


JessicaWoman99
posted 4-Dec-2007 9:56pm  

it does suck the way this teacher was treated it sucks hard
RGirl
posted 4-Dec-2007 10:26pm  

Definitely pissed off.
cloudhugger Survey Central SubscriberSilver Star Survey CreatorSurvey Qualifier
posted 4-Dec-2007 11:57pm  

Not pissed off, none of my business.
docgbrown
posted 5-Dec-2007 12:55am  

No, I am not pissed off, however... I did name a pair of my undershorts Muhammad
kirst
posted 5-Dec-2007 4:59am  

I am not "pissed off". I do think it's silly that she was arrested. I also think that people living in countries other than their own should educate themselves about the local culture.
autumnlight
posted 5-Dec-2007 7:36am  

Of course, it's an absolute joke. Thankfully she's been released and is now back in the UK.
Iseult Silver Star Survey Creator
posted 5-Dec-2007 12:18pm  

I really dislike the way she was treated. I don't know anything about this woman, so I can't really judge her character and her motives, but somebody who chooses to come to a war-torn country like a Sudan, so she could help out by teaching the kids, and this is the way they repay her?
LJD Bronze Star Survey CreatorGold Qualifier
posted 5-Dec-2007 12:27pm  

I think, without a doubt this is absurd. I feel the Muslim world have a serious problem with esteem...they have none. Because if they did, they could "turn the other cheek". I know here in the U.S. I see a serious problem on the horizon with the Muslims. Ismael will forever be angry he wasn't given the "birthright" by God. Islam in their treatment of women, is a sure sign it is not God's Word, or it's their interpretation. God says man is to treat his wife with respect, and love. Women are to treat their husband with the same, and be in submission. The problem is many men and women misinterpret this word. It means, since there can be only one head in the family, and the man is the headship, the woman should be submissive.. BUT before making decisions that will affect the family, besides his using his good judgment, he is to counsel with his wife, they are a working partnership. Men and women are to be humble.

I feel a REAL man doesn't have to beat his wife into submission, as the Muslim man feels. If a woman is a REAL woman, she'd be smart and know the right thing to do for the family. It's a mutual respect for each other.

I surely hope the government does something about this absurdity. But what can you expect, going into a country of less civility?
Frostbrand Bronze Star Survey Creator
(reply to LJD) posted 5-Dec-2007 2:15pm  

> I think, without a doubt this is absurd. I feel
> the Muslim world have a serious problem with esteem...they
> have none. Because if they did, they could
> "turn the other cheek". I know here in the U.S.
> I see a serious problem on the horizon with the
> Muslims. Ismael will forever be angry he wasn't
> given the "birthright" by God. Islam in their
> treatment of women, is a sure sign it is not God's
> Word, or it's their interpretation. God says
> man is to treat his wife with respect, and love.
> Women are to treat their husband with the same,
> and be in submission. The problem is many men
> and women misinterpret this word. It means, since
> there can be only one head in the family, and
> the man is the headship, the woman should be submissive..
> BUT before making decisions that will affect
> the family, besides his using his good judgment,
> he is to counsel with his wife, they are a working
> partnership. Men and women are to be humble.
>
> I feel a REAL man doesn't have to beat his wife
> into submission, as the Muslim man feels. If
> a woman is a REAL woman, she'd be smart and know
> the right thing to do for the family. It's a
> mutual respect for each other.
>
> I surely hope the government does something about
> this absurdity. But what can you expect, going
> into a country of less civility?

It's the 21st century and people still believe in God. THAT is what's absurd.
LJD Bronze Star Survey CreatorGold Qualifier
(reply to Frostbrand) posted 6-Dec-2007 8:12pm  

Frostbrand, I believe there will be a big turn back towards God's Word....which will be the one thing that will turn this country back to sanity...peoples eyes will be opened. The world is in the clutches of Satan right now....he is the god of this world. Things will be better one day, but there will be a lot of turmoil in the meantime, in the fight with the evil one....but we'll win, without a doubt.
Frostbrand Bronze Star Survey Creator
(reply to LJD) posted 6-Dec-2007 8:42pm  

Frostbrand, I believe there will be a big turn back towards Mickey Mouse's Word....which will be the one thing that will turn this country back to sanity...peoples eyes will be opened. The world
is in the clutches of Bugs Bunny right now....he is the god of this world. Things will be better one day, but there will be a lot of turmoil in the meantime, in the fight with the flappy eared one....but
we'll win, without a doubt.
mrmarm
posted 8-Dec-2007 8:19am  

I don't really care.
LindaH Survey Central Gold SubscriberGold Star Survey CreatorSurvey Qualifier
(reply to Frostbrand) posted 8-Dec-2007 1:24pm  

Does this mean Elmer Fudd is fighting the good fight?
flounderific
(reply to Frostbrand) posted 10-Dec-2007 6:35pm  

Kill da wabbit
smurf
posted 1-Jan-2008 9:56pm  

If I buy a teddybear for $10, name it 'Mohammed' then sell it for $20, have I made a prophet?
BigBobJoylove
posted 4-Jan-2008 8:16pm  

sick in the extreme - Gillian lives not far from me and we have renamed our cat Mohammed in protest



If you'd like to vote and/or comment on this survey, please Sign On.

 
Link this survey: http://surveycentral.org/survey/28293.html

Hits: 1 today (403 in the last 30 days)

Google Search:


This Month's BestBest ActiveBest InactivePick a CreatorPick a CategoryAll
New SurveyRepliesUsersSearchChatForumFeedbackStatisticsCustomizeHelp



Copyright © 1996-2008 Kenyon Hill LLC. All rights reserved.
Advertise on this site - Take our Poll - Privacy Statement - Subscribe - Donate - RSS RSS Feed