Sign On
Create Account

Last

TypeCreatedCategoryCreatorSortVotesHidesRating
single1-Aug-2006hypothetical questionZang by votes42657.9%

Advanced_Stats

Would you fire a male employee for wearing a miniskirt to a conference?

You're the CEO of a multinational corporation that exports heavy machinery for the transportation industry. Your company has numerous lucrative business connections in the Far East, the Persian Gulf etc. Recently you've spent months preparing to close a deal with a Japanese company that should realise millions of dollars in profits to your shareholders.

Raymond is the Vice President of Accounting. You've been working very closely with him on this Japanese deal. Several board members accompany the two of you on the flight to the headquarters in Yokohama. Everything is going as planned until the morning of the meeting. Raymond doesn't answer when you knock on the door of his hotel room. So you leave with the rest of the group, hoping he will catch up later. Just as you are walking into the conference room to meet the Japanese clients for the first time, Raymond burst out of the elevator and races into the room with you. He is wearing a dark business suit, but instead of pants, he has a black leather miniskirt.

The clients don't say anything, but it is obvious that they are disturbed by Raymond's mode of dress. Everyone tries to act like nothing is wrong and you continue with your presentation, but you have a sinking feeling that the whole deal is blown. You aren't expecting to close the deal today, that will come later in the week if it happens at all. You say nothing to Raymond until you can speak to him in private back at the hotel.



VotesAnswer
10I would warn Raymond not to do this again or he would face dismissal.
8I would fire Raymond.
5I would consult a lawyer.
4I would do something else.
2I would try to convince the clients that Raymond's outfit is acceptable.
1I would let Raymond dress any way he wanted.
0I would do nothing.

UserComment
clare
posted 2-Aug-2006 4:11am  
Initially I'd give him a warning about this, but I would consider firing him if it became obvious that his clothing choice caused the deal to not go through. At the very least a demotion.
Melf Gold Qualifier
posted 2-Aug-2006 7:18am  
I would warn Raymond not to do this again or he would face dismissal. I wouldn't let a woman wear a leather miniskirt to work, if I were boss.
dab Survey Central Subscriber Gold Qualifier
posted 2-Aug-2006 7:21am  
I wouldn't sit through the uncomfortable presentation, saying nothing. I'd pull him out immediately and find out what's going on. Probably fire him on the spot.
FordGuy Bronze Star Survey Creator Gold Qualifier
posted 2-Aug-2006 8:30am  
Is he wearing hosiery? Cuz mini skirts and bare legs are bad, bad, bad. IF he had the sense to wear some legwear, then all would be fine.

Why do I poke fun? Because this is a stupid question. NO international business deal is going to be broken by what some dude is wearing. Gosh, I hope he remembered his stilettos.
Biggles Bronze Star Survey Creator Gold Qualifier
posted 2-Aug-2006 8:38am  
Not in the first instance. I would think that dressing inappropriately should be grounds for dismissal, but since we're a big company I wouldn't even think of speaking to Raymond until I had first consulted with some lawyers. Assuming Raymond is usually reliable, I would go with the warning option in the first place, as long as the lawyers green-lighted that approach. I think another thing that I would consider, if Raymond said that he wanted to continue to dress that way, is giving him a backseat, i.e. removing him from having face to face contact with clients, but allowing him to continue working for the company.
Melf Gold Qualifier
(reply to Biggles) posted 2-Aug-2006 8:45am  
Good point; I never thought about consulting lawyers.
Biggles Bronze Star Survey Creator Gold Qualifier
(reply to Melf) posted 2-Aug-2006 8:48am  
Can you imagine not getting sued for unfair dismissal in a multinational corp?
Melf Gold Qualifier
(reply to Biggles) posted 2-Aug-2006 8:55am  
And the tabloids would have a field day.
Biggles Bronze Star Survey Creator Gold Qualifier
posted 2-Aug-2006 9:13am  
"Miniskirt man's multinational marching-orders"
judgescratch
posted 2-Aug-2006 9:13am  
I would warn Raymond not to do this again or he would face dismissal.

He needs to understand what's appropriate when and where. He's not corporate material without this basic understanding of tact.
paulyw Survey Central Subscriber Gold Star Survey Creator Gold Qualifier
posted 2-Aug-2006 10:23am  
I would fire him on the spot!
bill Survey Central Gold Subscriber Gold Star Survey Creator
posted 2-Aug-2006 11:10am  
It seems like deliberate sabotage given the situation. I'd wonder if Raymond has psychological problems. I'd fire him on the spot.
Amanda
posted 2-Aug-2006 11:36am  
I'd consult an attorney and see what course of action I could take without getting my ass sued.
Enheduanna Survey Central Subscriber
posted 2-Aug-2006 12:22pm  
I would probably talk to Raymond and find out what was going on.
BionicLips
posted 2-Aug-2006 12:52pm  
When you work for somebody else you follow his rules. Obviously Raymond's attire wasn't appropriate for that setting so he has to pay the consequences.
southernyankee Bronze Star Survey Creator
posted 2-Aug-2006 1:20pm  
I would warn him about it, since its his first offense. Firing him after the fact won't do you any good, unless it enboldens other employees to pull similar stunts. It also wouldn't be my place to try to convince the Japanese whats appropriate or not (it not the norm even here), your job is to do business with them.
kitti723
posted 2-Aug-2006 8:49pm  
I think I would talk with any one wearing a mini skirt to a business meeting whether they were male or female but especially male because it is a male dominant society and is not appropriate in any dress code for any male. It is up to company what is acceptable most of the time. There are always exceptions for men & women in dress codes in corporations as far as I've seen. They never mention men wearing stockings but sometimes insist women do. It's up to the man.
Zang
posted 2-Aug-2006 9:46pm  
I'd fire his ass on the spot.

If he had simply shown up for work dressed like that, it would have been no big deal. This is serious bad timing to be trying something like this.

On the other hand, if he had a good excuse...I don't think one exists, but if somehow he came up with an explanation that sounded reasonable, I might back off on the firing. I can't see that though.
Zang
posted 2-Aug-2006 9:48pm  
Incidentally, this is version two of a survey I did back in February. I'm guessing the results will be quite different.

http://surveycentral.org/survey/23713.html
Bittersweet19
posted 3-Aug-2006 7:05am  
Wow, this is a real thinking question. Well, I'd hate to lose a client but I don't want to upset or fire someone just because they tried a different style of clothing. I think I would talk to Raymond and ask him if he would dress more professionally while at work because work shouldn't be a place to show off new clothing or fashion. If he refuses, then it would depend on how this affected other opportunities. If several other clients backed down due to this I'd insist on a change or fire Raymond. Otherwise, I see no reason to.
verouge
posted 3-Aug-2006 9:09am  
 * duh! *

I would tell him not to do it again!
Enigma
posted 3-Aug-2006 10:58am  
I would consult a Lawyer about how to best fire him so his actions don't enable him to get money out of me. I would not have let him get much further than the door actually I would have escorted him out of the meeting. Upon returning I would explain to the clients that "Raymond has had a severe mental breakdown and would no longer be active with the account". Why so namby pamby about the situation? Unless the guy did have a mental breakdown he was obviously trying to sabotage the meeting. I'm not aware of the exact etiquette of international meetings but I'm sure mini-skirts (on women never mind men) is not acceptable.
LJD
posted 3-Aug-2006 4:20pm  
I think it was in very bad taste to wear a mini skirt, did not show as a professional. I would warn Raymond to never do it again, as his job is on the line, he will be fired if it should ever happen again.
ROCKMAN
posted 5-Aug-2006 9:39am  
I would probaby fire him.
cloudhugger
posted 6-Aug-2006 2:43pm  
I would try to convince the clients that Raymond's outfit is acceptable.
Remember the old 'Bewitched' series when Darren would have to explain quirky relatives of Samantha's to his clients..? Worked every time, everyone came out a winner.
Than I would fire his dumb iresponsible ass.
docgbrown
posted 14-Aug-2006 12:56pm  
I would talk to Raymond to get his story, consult a lawyer for next time and warn Raymond not to do this again or he would face dismissal.
Iseult Survey Central Subscriber Silver Star Survey Creator Gold Qualifier
posted 22-Aug-2006 9:30pm  
Fire Raymond for blowing the deal (if his gimmick had worked, I would've rewarded him) and consult a lawyer, too, just in case.
mve17
posted 23-Aug-2006 7:45pm  
I'd laugh my head off. I love Raymond!
Zang
(reply to mve17) posted 27-Aug-2006 3:44am  
> I'd laugh my head off. I love Raymond!

Everybody loves Raymond!  * wink *
mve17
(reply to Zang) posted 28-Aug-2006 9:14am  
Too true!  * raspberry *
RGirl
posted 9-Sep-2006 9:22pm  
I would fire Raymond AND consult a lawyer. Raymond was unprofessional and did something that could serious hurt the company. Let him wear a miniskirt with everyday business but he should know something this big calls for traditional dress. We're not trying to encourage diversity to a culture that is big on formality. We want the deal & if we could influence the people we would like to be in business with by all wearing leather mini skirts then we would all show up in one- for the company, business. The lawyer comes when the employee will undoubtedly try to sue the company for discrimination.
skirtsnhose
posted 15-May-2009 8:04pm  
I would fire Raymond for demonstrating excrutiatingly poor judgment. Everyone knows that you don't wear a leather miniskirt to a business meeting. If he wanted to wear a skirt to the meeting, he should have worn one that matched his suit coat.
Shadow47 New User
posted 23-Feb-2010 12:41pm  
Miniskirt might be my issue here. Close to the knee may be more appropriate for business. he he. Americans need to get over our hang-ups on some style of gender clothing
Last
Advanced_Stats

If you'd like to vote and/or comment on this survey, please Sign On

 
Link this survey: http://surveycentral.org/survey/24896.html

Hits: 1 today (17 in the last 30 days)